What the message means

Guideline 3.1.1 says that if you unlock features or functionality inside the app, you must use in-app purchase. Apple's examples are subscriptions, in-game currencies, game levels, premium content and unlocking a full version. Apps may not use their own unlock mechanisms. Apple names license keys, augmented reality markers, QR codes, cryptocurrencies and cryptocurrency wallets.

Two related rules apply. 3.1.1(a) covers links to other ways to buy. 3.1.3 lists the apps that may use other purchase methods.

Common causes

  • The app unlocks digital features or content with its own mechanism, such as an activation code or a license key, with no in-app purchase. 3.1.1 requires in-app purchase unless an exception in 3.1.3 applies.
  • The app shows a button or link to another way to pay where that is not allowed. Under 3.1.1(a), apps in specific regions can link out with a StoreKit External Purchase Link Entitlement or, where permitted, a Music Streaming Services Entitlement. In all other storefronts except the United States storefront, apps and their metadata may not include buttons, external links or other calls to action that direct people to other purchase methods.
  • There is no way to restore purchases. 3.1.1 asks for a restore mechanism for any restorable in-app purchase.
  • Purchased credits expire. 3.1.1 says credits or in-game currencies bought through in-app purchase may not expire.
  • The app sells digital gift cards, certificates, vouchers or coupons redeemable for digital goods or services outside in-app purchase. 3.1.1 says these can only be sold in the app with in-app purchase.
  • Loot boxes come without published odds. 3.1.1 asks you to disclose the odds of each item type before purchase.

Fix it step by step

  1. Sort what you sell. For each paid item, write down if people use it inside the app (digital) or outside it (physical goods, or services consumed outside the app).
  2. Check 3.1.3 before you rebuild payments. Physical goods and services used outside the app must use another method such as Apple Pay or card entry (3.1.3(e)). Reader apps, multiplatform services, enterprise services and one-to-one person-to-person services have their own rules in 3.1.3(a) to (d).
  3. Move digital unlocks to in-app purchase unless one of those exceptions applies. Create the products in App Store Connect and submit them together with the build.
  4. Remove calls to action for other payment methods from storefronts outside the United States where you do not hold an entitlement. Check the app and the metadata, including the description and screenshots.
  5. Add Restore Purchases where people can find it, and make sure purchased credits never expire.
  6. Explain the business model in the review notes if it is not obvious. The Business section says an unclear model can delay review and may lead to a rejection.

Reply in Resolution Center

Resolution Center is the App Review section of your app in App Store Connect. When you think an exception applies, cite it and describe the purchase in plain terms.

Hello App Review team,

Thank you for the note about Guideline 3.1.1.

What people buy in the app: [item] - [digital / physical / service used outside the app]

What we changed in build [number]:
- [e.g. Premium is now sold only as an auto-renewable in-app purchase]
- [e.g. removed the "Buy on our website" button outside the United States storefront]
- [e.g. added Restore Purchases in Settings > Account]

[If an exception applies:] We believe 3.1.3([letter]) applies because [one specific reason].

In-app purchase products in this submission: [product IDs]

Thank you,
[name]

Before you resubmit

  • Every digital feature or content unlock uses in-app purchase, unless an exception in 3.1.3 applies and the review notes name it.
  • No license keys, codes or QR codes unlock paid features.
  • Outside the United States storefront, the app and metadata contain no calls to action to other purchase methods unless you hold the entitlement for that storefront.
  • Restore Purchases is easy to find and works.
  • Credits bought with in-app purchase never expire.
  • The in-app purchase products are submitted with this build.
  • The review notes explain the business model and any exception you rely on.